… when it’s your first piece of full-length fiction is that you have no bloody idea whatsoever what constitutes a darn good ‘edit’.
I’m not talking about those typos, or the grammar choices (she had not driven there before/she’d not driven there before/she had never driven there before/she didn’t drive there) or those extra spaces after each full stop. They’ll all come later in what I believe might be called a line edit.
Yes, I’ve read blogposts and books and websites on editing. But I don’t think it’s until you have a go at editing your own work, that you realise what editing can truly involve.
For example, I had characters having conversations with each other, in person, who were not even meant to have flown into the country yet 🙈🙄 I mean, who do these people think they are?
Because I did not write this story in chronological order, my timelines were somewhat lacking authenticity. I’d created the majority of my 80,000 words in chunks of prose depending on my mood at the time of typing and slotting them in later … (Lovely, and that scene .. can … go roundabout .. sort of … THERE). And because it took til December to reach a point where I felt I could type those two rites of passage words ‘THE END’ it’s only very recently that I’ve read the whole thing through in one go.
I called it the ‘pink pen’ edit for the benefit of MoW and my insta writing buddies. There was an embarrassing amount to change, I mean seriously. Who told me I could write?? They have such a lot to answer for! Whole paragraphs got chopped and scribbles of much better prose ribboned their way around the edges of the margins. I didn’t have plot holes. I had craters you needed a plane to fly over to have any hope of crossing before dark. Anyway, I struggled on through and actually pink-penned my way to the end.
I have, I hope, made my characters more mindful of their present state of affairs; their internal dialogue needed to be thoughtful, less amateur dramatics with badly made costumes while throwing their arms about on a small tight stage, hoping for audience participation. This isn’t me belittling amateur dramatics for the record. I was a member of three groups in my twenties and loved every theatrical minute of those times 🎭 – playing up to audiences who came for no more than a night of fun, watching people they know deliver their old favourites. “A Handbag???” I played the part of the drunken reporter from The Yorkshire Argus in ‘The Importance of Being Ernest’ and I waved my arms around wildly on a small, tight stage hoping for audience participation – and got it!
Anyway, my point is, readers won’t pick up my book and say ‘oh look, it’s that nutty farmer’s wife. She’s written a novel, we’ve GOT to buy it, it’ll be sooo entertaining… darling? Darling? Where have you gone? You’ve got the purse!” (well maybe three of you might). I would like to think my potential readership will spot a book with an intriguing cover and title, a snappy blurb, a dramatic first paragraph and decide they want to know why Antonio is in one of Italy’s biggest prisons. They shouldn’t think about me when they read – I want them to disappear into the lives of Antonio, Martha and the others whose choices are dictating where the story goes.
Incorporating the pink pen edits back onto the laptop document has taken nearly a month. I nonchalantly assumed it would take a week but no-one warned me how painstaking that process is of keeping a finger on the ‘and’ you need to delete to make the sentence work, while finding which ‘and’ of the 186 on that page it is you’re trying to delete – Jesus and Mary and Joseph. And then there’s the spilling tea on the pages and hoping they’ll dry so you can still read the pink pen.
Not having a deadline (as no-one knows about this except you, MoW and me, and a handful of writerly friends) means there is no pressure. At one point when I was moving around the house like an author on a deadline with agent’s expectations hanging over me, my husband was eating crackers and cheese on his knee – no plate – and reminding me this was “meant to be fun?”. A hobby. He was right of course. All pressure I’d laid at my feet myself with that twinkle of devil suggesting I might not be able to do it. I’m permanently fighting my inner demons, wishing to prove to them that I can, but taking a few days off here and there to go watch a play in London or simply to tidy a room of clutter was all I needed to reset the default – my writing is a complete pleasure and meeting a need to be creative.
Today I have ten pages left of incorporating pink pen edits. It will have been a second read through and then I’m going to print the bugger off again (tiny font and double-sided and recycled paper) in order to check I’ve got the SAVE THE CAT 15-beats suggested within its brilliant pages … basically direction changes that link into our biological need to understand human behaviour (love all that stuff ☺️🥂).
But first, the royal we is tidying the kitchen as Mother is due at 11:30 for coffee. I’ve diabetes-friendly snacks on hand, a collection of Daily Telegraphs for dad, who won’t have stopped for days to read anything until those hours he can spend alone in his single bed in the back room while Mother languishes in her lace-covered double bed knobs and broomsticks bed at the front of the house with the bay window…..
[…] Last week I started another Curtis Brown Creative six week online course. I’ve already partaken in the first two of their set of three so having got to the end of my manuscript a few weeks ago, it seemed churlish not to do this one which is called EDIT & PITCH YOUR NOVEL. You’ll recall back in February, the experience of my attempts at editing left me somewhat vague as to what constituted a ‘good’ one. (If you didn’t see that, you can read it here.) […]
LikeLiked by 2 people
Great piece on editing. Writing is editing. At this point, I just try to get the damn thing down so I can go back to do the real part, the editing, because while it’s hard work, it’s extremely gratifying to take your own words and stories and improve them. Thanks for the post.
LikeLiked by 2 people
You’re so right – this is my first attempt yet I can already see where I’d get draft one down much more quickly when I start Book 2!!
LikeLike
Thank you this complete and honest share.🐬
LikeLiked by 2 people
So thrilled you’ve had a read and found it interesting ☺️
My editing journey moves on a pace and I’ve requested the new sets of eyes stage, I’d call it a beta read but I know the work is not in it’s finished form, but I’m still eager to here what the two readers think who offered to read it for me. I’ll pop across to you now 👏🏼🥂
LikeLike
I know that exciting feeling. very well. I love your energy and enthusiasm. I believe you are at your rippening. Best wishes dear friend.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Ha ha – I hope your novel is as hilarious as this. Editing is truly hard… I’m just going through the process of being edited – whereas before, being an indie author, although it was difficult, I could select what to edit. The first draft is always rough but at least you’ve got a first draft. Good luck and enjoy the different colour pens. xx
LikeLiked by 2 people
Hi Angela.. lovely to see you here xx
My novel isn’t funny and I think I’ve missed a trick here! It’s a romantic thriller.
I’m planning on making book 2 partially romcom funny though 👌🏼🤗
LikeLike
And wishing you so much luck with your edits xx
LikeLike
Nicely written and funny. I like the pink edit. Hope you are well.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Hey you!
Lovely to hear from you .. thank you for popping over and forgive me for not reading (any blog posts) for the best part of four months 🙈
I hope very much you are still writing and still laughing 🤗
LikeLiked by 2 people
Still writing, but not many blogs.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well that’s great .. 👌🏼
LikeLike
The joys. I’m afraid that’s the reason I disregard convention and stick with my first draft, a tidy-up here and there, and proofreading it to death for typos. No point in me looking for a publisher – I wouldn’t listen to them.
LikeLiked by 2 people
😂
Give me a few months and I’ll probably follow in your footsteps!
LikeLike
You perfectly describe the madness that is editing your own work. I use different coloured pens for each successive edit, not sure why, maybe it helps? Well, something needs to!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Quite!
I’m on page 51 with my purple pen and really enjoying this edit 💜
LikeLike
Reblogged this on anita dawes and jaye marie.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you lovely – how wonderful to meet you 🎉 I’m coming over now for a perusal 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Lovely to meet you too…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Absolutely love this, love that you are editing, it means you are closer! I am loving your progress posts. x
LikeLiked by 2 people
Aw thanks Jen xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
Reblogged this on Author Steve Boseley – Half a Loaf of Fiction and commented:
Someone else sharing the pain of editing…
LikeLiked by 2 people
Hi Steve 🥂
(oooh that’s a bit forward, sorry!)
Thank you so much for the reblog and I’m thrilled my rambling words hit a cord. Good luck with your editing also.
Popping over now to see what your bread is doing …
LikeLiked by 1 person
Welcome!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Many thanks 🤗
LikeLike
Steve, is your door open to this horror cafe of writerly things on this sunny morning?
Oh good, I’ll just park myself here awhile to give my wordpress toes a rest.
Coffee please, oh and one of those things under that glass dome would be superb.
Why do you have bat teeth at the window? No, you don’t have to tell me, it’s fine…. I was creative at school too.
Oh thank you.. that’s lovely.
Er… what’s that exactly? It looks remarkably like somebody’s ear.
I thought they were cinnamon swirls. Perhaps I’ll just pay and go.
Oh.
Your door has gone…
LikeLiked by 2 people
😀
LikeLike
Oh my goodness this certainly got me thinking.
The pink pen?
In school I am often asked to edit children’s work with pink and green pens; or green and pink pens; then ther are the purple pens or even the orange red or blue?
Getting the children to edit or peer mark their work is probably the hardest part…
But for me I don’t have a pen colour, maybe I need one?
LikeLiked by 2 people
Tee hee … I felt it was softer on myself than red but easy to read back 🌸
Thank you for popping over to read xx
LikeLike
It is indeed softer than red.
In Surrey they mark pink for perfect and green to grow better.
In Sussex it is green for good and pink to peek again to improve!
This blows my mind sometimes when i am required to mark all books I am always getting them round the wrong way.
Me I prefer just a green pen.
I think the school using Orange was because, perhaps, the pink was too soft.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for inserting humor into the editing world.
I thought writing would be the hardest part. But then I did that and it came time for editing. I’m really procrastinating on that and I think I need to set a deadline for myself, because things are just slipping. I’d rather outsource this part to someone else. If only it was that easy/ cheap.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Oh bless you … but the ‘someone else’ isn’t in your brain with your brilliant ideas for your novel 🤣
Let someone else beta read at some point yes. Let someone else line edit for typos and grammar yes.
But these early edits are still us laying the foundations of our story. It’s like standing back when the rooms are all laid out in breeze blocks but deciding to move the front door to the other side. Only we know where we want it xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
I really like your comparison and explanation.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Editing is a ^#&+^*. Sometimes, and I know there is such a thing as time constraints- coming back with fresh eyes works, as you can be in a different head/mind space than when you first wrote the words. I’ve been editing a longish work for a few months, and I get a new idea, and there goes a paragraph! Editing is a double-edged sword, but the work is richer from it .
LikeLiked by 2 people
That double edge sword is at work a lot, scraping my side! But I know you’re right. The more I read, the more I realise that there is good fiction which can be enjoyed but quickly forgotten, then great fiction which resonates and stays longer.
I’m hoping for the first as I don’t have the mind capacity for the latter 😂
Great to hear you are working on something too… I’m intrigued as to what it’s about!
LikeLike
Ahhhh I’ll soon be at this stage, though I already know what I need to chop! Basically the first half 😂😂 – Good on you for getting through it, first drafts are never nice and I wish you luck with moving onto the next round!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you Rebecca … same to you!
It’s great that you already know you need to lose some if it’s not working. So many new writers hang on to their prose like their hearts will stop beating without them!
LikeLike
I don’t think it’s embarrassing at all having a lot of changes to make in editing – it shows you’re aware of good practice and taking a critical eye. Embarrassing would be lack of awareness of this. Good luck with the edits.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Now I feel much better 💃🏼🥂
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Author S. L. Danielson and commented:
Editing is the hardest part for me, and I think…most writers.
LikeLiked by 2 people
If I say that’s great to know, I don’t mean I’m happy you struggle too 😂🙈 … but you know what I mean, in that it’s a relief even published authors still have their editing challenges.
Thank you for reading, commenting and I’m touched you re-blogged xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
No worries at all…I think every author deals with editing issues. You’re welcome!
LikeLiked by 1 person
At a time when I’m trying to keep my head above water whilst editing my 93,000-word-first-stab-at-a-novel… I really enjoyed this, Viola. Thank you.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Oh I’m so pleased it hit the spot Tessa. We are all in this together and any tips which I’ve found have eased the pressure I’ve always tried to share 🌸
The very best of luck with your edits x
LikeLike
I love reading about your process! You go, girl! I always think messiness is a good thing in writing… it means you’re thinking. I tell my students that a lot. (oh and I love pink pens! but maybe now you never want to look at another one 😂)
LikeLiked by 2 people
Oh Nora, how lovely to ‘see’ you here again 🌸
Your words mean the world to me xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
😍
LikeLike
So well said. It took me seven edits and 2 years to call it over for my book, for I don’t dare to read it again😊
LikeLiked by 2 people
The shows investment in your story and characters.. whom I suspect you’d started to get to know in your head before you even typed your first word?
Thank you for sharing.
I must pop over and read it myself!
LikeLiked by 1 person
My absolute pleasure – it was something to write a book – I learned a lot 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Reblogged this on Chris The Story Reading Ape's Blog.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you so much for the reblog 🤗 I hope the post helps other first-timers to keep going 🖌
LikeLiked by 1 person
I suspect it will, Viola 😃
LikeLiked by 1 person
Attention to detail…. yes, the task of editing! It’s not easy … being objective. It must be a wonderful feeling to be able to write, “The End.”
Unfortunately, the laborious task of editing, is yet another step forward… in the process! Hang in there…… almost there! 💙
LikeLiked by 2 people
Good on you for sticking with your edits, Viola. It really is a hard job, and one you don’t know is so hard until you’re right in the thick of it. Hang in there. Eventually you’ll get through the edits and see the huge difference they make to your manuscript 😊.
LikeLiked by 2 people
So true …. thank you for the encouragement 🌸🤗
LikeLiked by 1 person
I‘m just about to start my first developmental editing (I believe that’s what your describing 😊) too! I started off with my not pink but diamond pen 😂 that came with my content planner – as it makes me feel very effective indeed – but after chapter ine I wondered whether I don’t just want to make the changes directly on my laptop! What do you think?
LikeLiked by 2 people
I couldn’t agree with you more…
Seeing the words on the page made it easier to be objective. It was like I could be reading someone else’s work.
I was also able to take it to whatever spot in the house I fancied in a old folder, take my cup of tea, your diamond pen and get scribbling.
I enjoyed the two weeks away from the screen to be honest.
Do it. Xxx
LikeLiked by 1 person